Custom Gifts

Made Easy

Shop Small Now

Meaningful gifts made by American artists

How It Works

1 Questionnaire

Complete an easy order questionnaire about your recipient's likes, dislikes, quirks, & stories.

Leave the rest to us.

2 Match-Making

We match your order with a talented and vetted artist, based on preferences from the questionnaire.

We make matches that wow!

3 Gift Creation

Your artist creates a one-of-a-kind gift inspired by your answers.

The artist & gift will be a surprise. Trust us, it'll be special.

4 Wrap & Ship

Your gift is shipped straight to its destination, wrapped with a handwritten note from the artist.

The entire process takes about 3 weeks.

Why Choose Us

5-Star

Vetted Artists

No guesswork or reading questionable online reviews.

We get to know every one of our artists. We understand their work and know their quality is top notch.

Let us do the work

No wasted time or stress finding a special gift.

We work with our artists to ensure each gift is unique and reflective of the giftee's preferences, quirks, and stories.

Support American small businesses

No wondering where your gift was made.

All of our artists are state-side. They ship their custom gifts from their workshops to your recipient.

Your gift supports American makers.

Pricing

Choose your price for your custom gift

All gifts are one-of-a-kind and made by vetted artists

Support American makers. A more generous price point pays for more artist time.

$155

$195

$350

Free Shipping

Looking to order multiple gifts for business or family?

Multiple Orders Info

Gift Examples

A decorative mirror matching specific patterns found on the giftee's Pinterest page. Tree detailing matches a story shared by the giver.

A serving tray and coaster set made with real pressed flowers.

The giftee loves to garden and entertain.

An art doll inspired by the Instagram photos of the giftee.

A watercolor painting which tells the story of the emotions in the questionnaire.

The giftee is a social worker.

A mirrored wall hanging that captured the specific interests in the questionnaire.

The giftee loves tea, chess, and their pet rat.

A pottery and hand-bound journal set using pressed leaves. Inspired by the giftee's love of nature and favorite colors.

A framed composite photo print inspired by the giftee's love of lighting and whimsy.

A set of decorative embroidery hoops with the giftee's catchphrases and dry sense of humor.

An art doll that tells the story of a traveler. Perfect for the giftee, who always wanted a doll as a child.

Why Go Custom?

A Gift That Tells A Story

Show you care by giving something meaningful and memorable.

Our artists will craft a gift as unique as your recipient.

Perfect for the Hard to Please

Don't know what to give?

Don't have time to search?

No problem!

Let Tell Me More Gifts

do the work for you.

Support Makers, Shop Small

Support a small, ethics-led, female-founded business, that connects American artists with orders.

Shop and gift with heart.

Testimonials

"What a fun way for a surprise gift! I loved having the opportunity to describe my friend through the questionnaire and then know that a special artist would create a gift just for them. Truly a unique adventure for both the giver and the recipient!"

PJ, Gift Giver for Others

"A great concept I've never heard of before. And the process was super fun and easy! I just filled out a fun quiz that asked me a good range of questions about the gift recipient – in this case, me!

My gift was beautiful and fit right in with my home, and I loved reading the personalized postcard from the artist about which of my questions sparked her imagination.

The team was really lovely and I followed my artist on social media because I loved their work so much!

I could use this for so many events, like weddings or anniversaries! It's so flexible and useful, I'm rethinking the way I search for and buy gifts.

I'll absolutely order from Tell Me More Gifts again!"

Lalaith, Gift Giver for Self